Author: Pamela Christian

Does Raising Monarchs Hurt Them?

A Look at Why Small-Scale Rearing Matters

At Whimsical Wings Farms, we believe that hands-on experience inspires a lifelong love of nature. Our Monarch Butterfly Kits are designed to give children, families, and classrooms the chance to witness the magic of the butterfly life cycle — while also supporting monarch conservation efforts.

However, you may have seen articles online suggesting that raising monarchs in captivity can be harmful. We care deeply about monarch health, so we want to share the facts — and explain why small-scale, responsible rearing (like what we support) is not only safe, but important.

What Some Researchers Say

Recent research has shown that monarchs raised in large, commercial operations sometimes:

    •    Have lower migration success compared to wild monarchs

    •    Develop slightly smaller or paler wings

    •    Experience higher rates of disease if raised in crowded conditions

These studies raise important concerns — but they mainly focus on mass production environments where thousands of monarchs are raised in confined spaces without live plants or natural conditions.

Why Our Kits Are Different

At Whimsical Wings Farms, we do things very differently.

Here’s why our kits support healthy, strong monarchs:

1. Small Scale, Natural Environment

    •    Our kits include just a few caterpillars at a time, not hundreds or thousands.

    •    Low-density rearing minimizes stress and disease — much closer to what happens in the wild.

2. Live Milkweed Plants

    •    Every kit includes a live milkweed plant, not just cut leaves.

    •    Monarch caterpillars get continuous access to fresh, high-quality food, which is vital for strong growth and healthy wings.

3. Clean, Healthy Rearing Practices

    •    We provide clear instructions for keeping enclosures clean and caterpillars healthy.

    •    Our setup helps prevent overcrowding and common parasites like OE.

4. Conservation Through Education

    •    Children who experience the butterfly life cycle firsthand are more likely to grow into adults who care about habitat protection and pollinator conservation.

    •    Without that emotional connection, it’s harder to inspire real-world action for monarchs.

But Do Captive-Reared Monarchs Migrate?

Some studies suggest migration success may be lower in captive monarchs — but it’s important to know:

    •    Many reared monarchs still migrate successfully, especially when reared in healthy, natural-like conditions.

    •    Research in the western U.S. (where migrations are shorter) shows captive-reared monarchs doing especially well.

    •    Even monarchs that don’t migrate still breed locally, helping strengthen wild populations where milkweed is scarce.

In short: when done properly, rearing monarchs is not harmful — it’s a meaningful way to support both education and conservation.

Our Promise to You — and the Monarchs

We are deeply committed to raising healthy butterflies the right way.

When you purchase a Monarch Kit from Whimsical Wings Farms, you’re doing more than raising a butterfly.

You’re planting a habitat, creating future conservationists, and helping monarchs thrive for generations to come.

Thank you for being part of this important journey with us!

Have questions about monarch rearing or conservation?

Feel free to reach out anytime at help@whimsicalwingsfarms.com

Ever Wonder How Butterflies Pollinate?

They pollinate by transferring pollen from one flower to another as they feed on nectar. Here’s how it works step by step:

  1. Attracted to Flowers: Butterflies are drawn to brightly colored flowers (especially white, red, yellow, and purple) with a strong scent and a wide landing platform.
  2. Nectar Feeding: They land on the flower and use their long, straw-like tongue (called a proboscis) to reach deep into the flower for nectar.
  3. Pollen Transfer: While feeding, their legs and bodies may brush against the flower’s reproductive parts—the stamens (which produce pollen) and the pistils (the pollen-receiving part). Some pollen sticks to the butterfly.
  4. Next Flower Visit: When the butterfly visits another flower, some of that pollen rubs off onto the new flower’s pistil, enabling fertilization.

Butterflies aren’t as efficient as bees when it comes to pollination because they have slender bodies and less surface area for pollen to stick to, but they still play an important role—especially for certain wildflowers that depend on them.

Why Choose Monarchs Over Painted Ladies?

Raising butterflies is magical no matter the species — but there’s something truly special about the Monarch experience.

1. A Real Connection to Nature

    •    Monarch caterpillars eat only milkweed, which means you get to raise them on a living, growing plant — not a cup of artificial diet (see the video below).

    •    This gives you a front-row seat to real garden ecology, pollinator awareness, and plant-insect interaction.

    •    Painted Ladies are usually raised on a paste-like artificial diet in a cup — quick and convenient, but far removed from nature.

2. A “Luckier” Lifecycle

    •    Painted Ladies can feel like an “assembly line” experience: caterpillars in a cup, butterflies out in a week, and done.

    •    Monarchs offer a longer, more thoughtful journey — from caterpillar to chrysalis to butterfly, often over 2–3 weeks.

    •    Watching a Monarch chrysalis shift from jade green to transparent gold is truly breathtaking — and worth the wait.

3. Conservation You Can See

    •    Monarch populations are in decline, and raising them helps support their survival.

    •    By planting milkweed and raising Monarchs, you’re making a real difference in pollinator conservation.

    •    Painted Ladies aren’t threatened, and raising them doesn’t have the same ecological impact.

In short:

Painted Ladies are fun. Monarchs are unforgettable.

With Monarchs, you raise more than a butterfly — you grow a connection to the natural world, and become part of something bigger.

To download the Classroom Comparison Chart, click here.

With our kit, you get to enjoy watching the caterpillars munch down the milkweed plant!

The Amazing Monarch Migration

The monarch butterfly migration is one of the most remarkable natural phenomena in the world. Monarchs (Danaus plexippus) undertake a multi-generational migration spanning thousands of miles across North America. Their journey is unique because no single butterfly completes the entire round trip—rather, it takes four to five generations to complete the full cycle.

The Migration Cycle

Spring Migration (Northward Journey)

• In March and April, monarchs begin their journey north from Mexico and Southern California, where they have spent the winter in dense forest groves.

• These butterflies lay eggs on milkweed plants across the southern U.S. before dying.

• The next generation hatches, matures, and continues the journey north.

Summer Generations

• Over the next few months (May to August), multiple generations are born in the U.S. and Canada.

• Each new generation moves farther north, following the growth of milkweed, their host plant.

• These summer monarchs live for about 2-6 weeks and continue reproducing.

Fall Migration (Southward Journey)

• The last generation of the year, known as the “super generation,” is born in late summer (August-September).

• Unlike their short-lived ancestors, these butterflies can live up to 8 months.

• They do not reproduce immediately; instead, they focus on flying up to 3,000 miles south to their wintering grounds.

Overwintering in Mexico and California

• Monarchs from eastern North America migrate to the mountains of central Mexico (specifically, the oyamel fir forests in Michoacán).

• Monarchs from western North America migrate to coastal California, clustering in groves of eucalyptus, cypress, and pine trees.

• They remain in their overwintering sites until the weather warms up in February or March, when the cycle begins again.

Threats to Monarch Migration

• Habitat Loss: Deforestation in Mexico and urban expansion in North America threaten critical habitats.

• Declining Milkweed Populations: Monarchs depend on milkweed to lay eggs, but widespread herbicide use has drastically reduced its availability.

• Climate Change: Unseasonal temperatures, severe storms, and droughts disrupt migration timing and survival rates.

How to Help Monarch Butterflies

• Plant native milkweed and nectar-rich flowers.

• Avoid using pesticides that harm butterflies and caterpillars.

• Support conservation efforts to protect overwintering sites.

• Participate in citizen science projects to track monarch populations.

Monarch migration is both fragile and awe-inspiring. Scientists continue to study this phenomenon, and conservationists work to ensure future generations can witness this incredible journey.

The Amazing Monarch Migration

The monarch butterfly migration is one of the most remarkable natural phenomena in the world. Monarchs (Danaus plexippus) undertake a multi-generational migration spanning thousands of miles across North America. Their journey is unique because no single butterfly completes the entire round trip—rather, it takes four to five generations to complete the full cycle.

The Migration Cycle

Spring Migration (Northward Journey)

    • In March and April, monarchs begin their journey north from Mexico and Southern California, where they have spent the winter in dense forest groves.

    • These butterflies lay eggs on milkweed plants across the southern U.S. before dying.

    • The next generation hatches, matures, and continues the journey north.

    Summer Generations

    • Over the next few months (May to August), multiple generations are born in the U.S. and Canada.

    • Each new generation moves farther north, following the growth of milkweed, their host plant.

    • These summer monarchs live for about 2-6 weeks and continue reproducing.

    Fall Migration (Southward Journey)

    • The last generation of the year, known as the “super generation,” is born in late summer (August-September).

    • Unlike their short-lived ancestors, these butterflies can live up to 8 months.

    • They do not reproduce immediately; instead, they focus on flying up to 3,000 miles south to their wintering grounds.

    Overwintering in Mexico and California

    • Monarchs from eastern North America migrate to the mountains of central Mexico (specifically, the oyamel fir forests in Michoacán).

    • Monarchs from western North America migrate to coastal California, clustering in groves of eucalyptus, cypress, and pine trees.

    • They remain in their overwintering sites until the weather warms up in February or March, when the cycle begins again.

    Threats to Monarch Migration

    • Habitat Loss: Deforestation in Mexico and urban expansion in North America threaten critical habitats.

    • Declining Milkweed Populations: Monarchs depend on milkweed to lay eggs, but widespread herbicide use has drastically reduced its availability.

    • Climate Change: Unseasonal temperatures, severe storms, and droughts disrupt migration timing and survival rates.

    How to Help Monarch Butterflies

    • Plant native milkweed and nectar-rich flowers.

    • Avoid using pesticides that harm butterflies and caterpillars.

    • Support conservation efforts to protect overwintering sites.

    • Participate in citizen science projects to track monarch populations.

    Monarch migration is both fragile and awe-inspiring. Scientists continue to study this phenomenon, and conservationists work to ensure future generations can witness this incredible journey.

    LILESVILLE, N.C., April 3, 2025 (SEND2PRESS NEWSWIRE) — Whimsical Wings Farms, a leader in butterfly conservation and pollinator education, is proud to announce a breakthrough in plant shipping: a patented box designed to safely deliver one-gallon milkweed plants. Paired with the farm’s engaging Monarch Butterfly Lifecycle Kit, the innovation supports nationwide habitat restoration efforts and hands-on environmental education.

    Read the Press Release here.

    Spring is here, and that beautiful patch of clover in your yard? It’s not a weed — it’s a lifeline. Bees, butterflies, and other pollinators rely on blooming clover and wildflowers for food, especially early in the season.

    Did you know pollinators are dangerously close to extinction? Pesticides, habitat loss, and lack of food sources are pushing them to the brink.

    This year, let’s do something simple but powerful:

    Skip the pesticides. Let your clover grow. Welcome the wild.

    Your yard can be a safe haven — a small patch of hope in a world that’s getting harder for pollinators to survive in.

    Plant kindness. Let it bloom.

    #PollinatorFriendly #SaveTheBees #NoPesticides #LetItGrow #MonarchButterfly 

    Artificial Pollination

    Artificial pollination is not replacing natural pollinators but rather supplementing them in situations where they are declining or insufficient. Natural pollinators, such as bees, butterflies, and birds, play an irreplaceable role in ecosystems, supporting biodiversity and agricultural production. However, due to habitat destruction, pesticide use, climate change, and diseases, many pollinator populations are in decline.

    A Wonderful World (and Yard)

    “I see trees of green, Red roses too.
    I see them bloom, For me and you
    And I think to myself, What a wonderful world”
    – Lyrics to “A Wonderful World” by Louis Armstrong

    This song always makes me think of beautiful yards.  But a beautiful yard is in the eyes of the beholder.  Personally, I love my “white” yard.    Lots of people see clover or other wild flowers in the yard as a weed and/or foe.   But did you know that these wild flowers are what the pollinators survive on in the spring?   The garden flowers have not yet bloomed, but the pollinators are already out and about, and need sustenance.   That’s where these lovely flowers come into play and are a staple in the feeding of pollinators.

    I know people love a lush green yard.   But do you know the consequences of having one?   If you eradicate the clover and other wild flowers from your yard with chemicals, not only are you killing off the much needed food for all the pollinators, but you are also killing the insects that live in the soil as well as your local song birds that feed off these insects.

    Instead of using chemicals, EMBRACE the wild flowers growing in your yard.   You will be amazed with all the creatures that will enjoy them.   And in turn, you will get to enjoy knowing you have a pollinator friendly yard and will be rewarded with these wonderful whimsical winged creatures.   What a wonderful world, indeed.

    My Cart